Movie Review: Judgemental Hai Kya (2019)

Box Office: TBA

A brutal childhood trauma leaves Bobby (Kangana Ranaut) diagnosed with acute psychosis in her adult years. And after doing time at an asylum for assaulting a coworker, she is let off on the condition that she will stick with her medication. Bobby is a dubbing artist for movies, where she is the voice of the female lead characters. And interestingly, her mind is a medley of all the characters she has voiced. For every time she dubs, she gets obsessed with her onscreen avatar and imagines herself in place of the character. This obsession is dealt with a narrative treatment that’s cool and quirky.

To bring out this element of madness in her further, there’s also a busy wall in her house that’s has photographs of her dressed as every character she has dubbed for. And deep down, Bobby yearns to be an actor herself, something that her manager cum so-called boyfriend, Varun (Hussain Dalal), is unable to pull off. So he ends up grocery shopping with her more often than ‘getting lucky’ on actual dates. When he protests, she tells him without batting an eyelid, “Tum aloo ke jaise nahin ho sakte… easy going and adjusting. Be like aloo.”

In the midst of this existence, enter Keshav and Rima (Rajkummar Rao and Amyra Dastur) as her new tenants and a much in love couple. And Bobby gets drawn to their love story which in her world is too good to be true. But then a murder breaks this momentum and Bobby believes Keshav is the culprit. Is it her overactive imagination or has her anxiety and psychosis led her to do this instead? The characters here are twisted… and you are left wondering, trying to figure which of the two has blood on their hands.



Good Reviews  |  Average Reviews  |  Bad Reviews
Good Reviews  |  Average Reviews  |  Bad Reviews
Positive Reviews
4.0 “Fawlessly performed, brilliantly crafted, dark & beautiful”
4.0 “Kangana Ranaut dazzles in a film about mind games”
3.5 “Judgementall Hai Kya leaves plenty of room for doubt and even sympathy for the delusional.”
3.5 “‘Judgementall Hai Kya’ keeps the element of suspense alive all the way till the end, as it pushes the envelope as a dark, psychological whodunit, with a social message weaved in that can’t be ignored.”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut, Rajkummar Rao are flawless in this unconventional thriller”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut’s Bravura Performance Steals the Show”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut, Rajkummar Rao Lead This Cinema Which Is Beyond All Reasons!”
3.5 ” South director Prakash Kovelamudi makes a confident debut in Hindi cinema.”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut-Rajkummar’s insanity sanitises a whodunit”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut steals the show in trippy black comedy”
3.5 “Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao Kill it In this Crazy Thriller”
3.0 “JUDGEMENTALL HAI KYA is a well-made film with powerful performances from both Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao.”
3.0 “Rajkummar Rao Is Ideal Foil To Livewire Kangana Ranaut In Zany Psychological Drama”
3.0 “Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao starrer is one of its kind, bizarre fun”
3.0 “Totally bonkers”
3.0 “Kangana hits all the notes perfectly”
Average Reviews
2.5 “This Kangana-Rajkummar Film Has Its Share Of Hits & Misses!”
Negative Reviews
2.0 “The film is tiresome.”

Tagged , ,

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *